[10:50:36] [1/2] Trying again: @Global Administrators https://login.miraheze.org/wiki/User:KSArts12/Who_is_Mengphayu888 [10:50:36] [2/2] This is smear campaign against another user. [11:02:39] I disagree - the only part that's questionable is the statement about broken English, which is not by itself a policy violation [11:14:23] [1/4] I personally think it is not done to create a page about other users with the sole purpose to put them in a bad light. And perhaps the @Stewards or the community as a whole have to discuss this. [11:14:23] [2/4] If we allow users to put others down, we find ourselves on a slippery slope. I would like to get a more clear borderline of what is allowed, especially on Meta. [11:14:23] [3/4] And as @notaracham stated in one of his declines recently `we generally do not permit wikis focused on individuals.` Why should we allow that on Userpages on meta then? [11:14:23] [4/4] I find that contradictory. [11:15:02] Different matter, different reason [11:19:25] [1/3] Not sure I agree. But I digress on that statement then. [11:19:25] [2/3] Still would like to know where we draw the line on creating userpages about others. [11:19:25] [3/3] I know that Miraheze is relaxed about userpages. But we also need to have some moral compass to keep Meta from becoming a toxic community, which such pages easily can contribute to. [11:20:08] My view is rather that login wiki shouldn't permit _any_ pages including user-subpages other than userpages for GUP reasons [11:20:25] I don't like any other pages on loginwiki as it's not actively moderated (and shouldn't need to be) [11:21:20] My preference would be to disable createpage via AF and have an exception for userpages only not including subpages [11:23:05] That's tricky, due to the fact that Userpages often are made on Templates from the subpages, (Like I do for example) [11:23:48] Ah, right. In that case I'd also be fine with simply enforcing a rule that no content other than templates for userpages is allowed on loginwikj [22:51:30] Whats login wiki? [23:07:29] The wiki that handles everything like SSO and global accounts [23:57:42] [[mh:login:]] [23:57:42] https://mh.wikipedia.org/wiki/login: [23:57:43] [23:59:11] Let's try that again [[:login:]] [23:59:11] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/:login: [23:59:12]