[01:51:11] so if I'm reading the API docs correctly, it looks like all edits happen with post requests but don't use the body? ... why? [08:28:05] [1/2] https://issue-tracker.miraheze.org/T16002#325037 [08:28:05] [2/2] Any thoughts on issue 5 for temporary accounts? [08:34:04] > Per [T337090](https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/mediazilla:T337090) it might be a good idea to start [temporary account] numbers from 1500 (or we could even do 10000 so that it's a nicer number) to avoid hitting numbers considered inappropriate. [10:17:03] [1/2] Personally I don't really care. For me 88 is an old Chinese internet slang meaning "goodbye", the same way 666 is interpreted very differently in different cultures. Someone can still create a named account with a bad number in it anyway, so I don't see a reason to be extra cautious around temp accounts. [10:17:04] [2/2] With that said, I do think it'll be preferable to start with a larger number if only to make account names longer and more uniform. [10:28:09] And now that I think about it, this could/should be answered by CVT/Steward/T&S. [12:51:54] if someone makes an account with certain numbers in their name, that was their decision. Whereas if I'd automatically been assigned an account with a number co-opted by fascist movements, and now my edit is permanently associated with that number, I wouldn't behappy [12:55:04] I don't mind starting from large number since we now have influx of chinese editors [15:07:55] My 2c, this is one case where I am not opposed to copying Ma Wiki, frankly I don’t super care and don’t think this needs to be a hard decision [21:04:25] [1/2] Woohoo first temporary account created [21:04:25] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1006789349498699827/1558948410571366450/image.png?ex=6acd4b58&is=6acbf9d8&hm=5dca285a97f836637e4dd072aa93e5a2e967dbcb6aec692ab4c9b6ae6fffb5ff& [21:10:49] Yayyyyy [22:14:49] should we start opening this up to more wikis now? [22:24:28] The page on Meta says request on SR/RC, so we'll see if any wiki makes a request. [22:25:03] cc @lynn.in [22:25:42] ^ https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Tech:Temporary_accounts [22:27:39] I used some scary language because I'm not sure about how well temp accounts will function. We'll see. [22:27:45] From WO's experience nothing catastrophic will happen, but small bugs are bound to be seen. I've already seen one with UPV2. [22:28:04] I guess this is a good opportunity to @originalauthority about this MR: https://gitlab.com/telepedia/extensions/userprofilev2/-/merge_requests/14 [22:28:45] I think this page could do with a list or a link to a list to extensions with known incompatibilities rather than only a big long list of every extension [22:29:47] Do you mean T15186? I was thinking of making some JS that automatically checks every enabled extension on a wiki against the Phorge task to report untested extensions. [22:30:22] yes that one [22:32:10] I think we'd probably want to make sure Stewards & T&S & CVT are all happy with how it's working [22:34:33] [1/2] strinova.org got edits from 4 distinct IPs in the past month so it won't serve as a good testing ground on the CVT side. Could be good for testing a few extensions, though. [22:34:33] [2/2] Ideally we want a wiki that is large enough for IP edits to come frequently and has enough admins patrolling changes to not cause problems for CVT. [22:34:45] With how it's configured at the moment, I'm not sure anyone can even see the underlying IPs [22:35:04] @posix_memalign I mean we could still do some dummy edits and let them do things like CU [22:35:57] IP info rights and checkuser-temp-account are all available to no one at the moment [22:36:02] [1/2] AFAIK IPInfo doesn't show anything against them. I can grant myself CU and CU my temp accounts on beta as a test. [22:36:02] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1006789349498699827/1558971465607413840/image.png?ex=6acd60d1&is=6acc0f51&hm=fe0adc3f615f2a798c88562d202a17de763d0279e85a81769fc77230dae7e1a3& [22:36:06] Which feels like a missed step [22:36:32] Did we forget adding the IPinfo DB? [22:36:38] I think there's a free version of it [22:39:26] [1/2] Perhaps we did and it could be missing in prod as well. We can ask GAs how it looks like when they look at IP contributions. [22:39:26] [2/2] But if we do it will reveal the location and ASN of temp accounts to GAs. I personally think this is acceptable but per T&S's current position we should not let GAs gain access to anything related to the underlying IP of a temp account. [22:40:30] https://github.com/miraheze/puppet/blob/00bd9622c4004069b299919d609fcdd86fe42b21/modules/matomo/manifests/init.pp#L19 [22:40:53] We really should solve all this before deploying it any further [22:41:01] I don't think we've thought about this at all [22:41:10] Only done on matomo it seems? [22:42:09] It's in private puppet so we could deploy it to the mediawiki servers too [22:42:27] I'm not sure how much use it will be as the full version costs [22:42:32] It came up in https://issue-tracker.miraheze.org/T16002#325031 but I thought it isn't a blocker since the current dysfunction works better for user privacy. [22:42:48] But it will at least give you the country the temp account is in [22:44:03] Did T&S ever say anything about whether we can give GA access to that? [22:44:25] In the meantime I forgot how to give myself local CU so I need to figure out how I can test this in beta [22:45:11] I don't think anywhere in the tasks T&S have signed off on anything [22:45:38] And we haven't tested CU which can't be done without T&S consent [22:45:41] Even on beta [22:46:16] I'm not sure why temp accounts have been deployed tbh [22:46:59] And I definitely don't think we should be deploying to more wikis until we know at least basic anti abuse functions work and our teams know how to do anything different [22:47:18] The full IPInfo data is paid and expensive [22:49:11] https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/rOPUPe04967dba5ddaf145f605064d7cf10cc6b7b64fe is interesting [22:49:17] They changed from Maxmind [22:50:17] AFAIK CU can always be done on Beta as long as the target is the same person as the one initiating CU [22:50:44] Which was how tech tested CheckUser on beta for prior MW upgrades [22:52:44] We can use the free versions based on https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:IPInfo of the Maxmind data although licensing is questionable [22:52:52] It doesn't really meet their terms [22:53:13] The WMF decided to make IPInfo dependant on expensive paid subscriptions because why not [22:53:30] Cc @kostajh for any thoughts on my rant there [22:54:08] _thinks all this should have been planned long before we deployed temp accounts to the first wiki and is going back to bed_ [22:54:44] The last comment from T&S I've seen was that all temp account-related PII can only be seen by NDA holders, which the current deployment honors (and might in fact be stricter). But I figured out how to do local CU so I'll see what happens. [22:55:18] [1/2] Just CUed myself and I can see my IP, so I think we have complied with the strictest possible interpretation of what T&S has said. [22:55:18] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1006789349498699827/1558976314315382874/image.png?ex=6acd6555&is=6acc13d5&hm=4bb5af3c10133e8c34bbd5a56a9918f86472da17e8dc8c066d418b3c372e62cc& [22:57:14] (that is, NDA holders such as stewards and T&S can see IPs; GAs cannot see anything) [23:11:32] thank you