[16:59:10] XioNoX: Runing snmpbulkget -v2c -c community mr1-eqsin.wikimedia.org 1.3.6.1.2.1.14.7.1.12 [16:59:13] Returns the proper data with no need for retries [16:59:24] I just tried that and it didn't work for me [16:59:26] it timed out [16:59:31] yep [16:59:32] Timeout: No Response from mr1-eqsin.wikimedia.org [16:59:45] but getbulk fails [16:59:50] so snmpbulkget did _not_ work [17:00:30] oh wait [17:00:36] -c community is a placeholder I guess [17:00:37] heh [17:00:53] lemme find the right one :) [17:04:13] ok, with the right one both snimpy + snmpbulkget work [17:04:33] ah yeah, I forgot what I said in the task :) [17:04:36] so I can't reproduce [17:04:46] I don't see retries at all [17:05:40] do you have a test case? [17:05:53] mine is at icinga1001:~faidon/test-eqsin.py [17:06:53] on the phone, can look later [17:07:09] k [17:07:11] I'm off for now [17:07:13] reproduce as running manually the icinga check? [17:10:43] yeah so [17:10:52] the SRX takes ~1.5s to respond [17:11:07] 1.6s actually, but including the eqiad-eqsin RTT [17:11:35] snimpy sends a request, and then waits 1s until it retries again [17:11:48] (and then does that 1+3 retries = 4 times) [17:12:12] and then the SRX responds all 4 times [17:12:20] and then all hell breaks loose basically :) [17:12:34] so it's either upgrade the SRX in case it becomes faster [17:12:39] or fix the check to not retry every second [17:12:55] gotta go now [17:12:56] ttyl! [17:16:36] good findings! that's also one of my points in the task, fix snimpy so if respects the timeout parameter [17:16:59] I didn't dig deeper on it though